Top 10 Used Guns on GunBroker – September 2025 Rankings and Insights
Welcome back to our monthly roundup of the Top Selling Used Guns on GunBroker 2025. September 2025 used firearms rankings reveal a fascinating snapshot of what America’s gun enthusiasts, firearm collectors, and hunters are buying.
From classic revolvers to iconic rifles and shotguns, the used gun market shows both brand loyalty and timeless demand for proven performers and budget-friendly favorites.
Don’t Miss the July & August reports of the Top Selling Used Guns on GunBroker 2025. And come back monthly for our future reports.
About This List:
This list shows the top ranked used firearms on GunBroker for September 2025. It highlights the most popular handguns, rifles, and shotguns for each firearm category in the used market.
Top Selling Used Guns on GunBroker in September 2025 [Data & Rankings]: Top 10 Highlights
| Rank | Category | Manufacturer | Model | Previous Rank | Shop Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Semi Auto Pistols | Sig Sauer | P320 | 1 | Buy Now |
| 1 | Revolvers | Ruger | Single Six | 2 | Buy Now |
| 1 | Semi Auto Rifles | Springfield | M1 Garand | 1 | Buy Now |
| 1 | Bolt Action Rifles | Remington | Model 700 | 1 | Buy Now |
| 1 | Lever Action Rifles | Winchester | Model 94 | 1 | Buy Now |
| 1 | Single Shot Rifles | Thompson Center | Encore | 1 | Buy Now |
| 1 | Semi Auto Shotguns | Remington | Model 1100 | 1 | Buy Now |
| 1 | Pump Action Shotguns | Remington | 870 Wingmaster | 1 | Buy Now |
| 1 | Over Under Shotguns | Browning | Citori | 1 | Buy Now |
| 1 | Side By Side Shotguns | Browning | BSS | 10 | Buy Now |
And don’t miss this month’s 24 Most Expensive Items Sold on GunBroker | September 2025.
1. SIG SAUER P320 – Handgun, Semi Auto Pistols (Rank #1)
The SIG Sauer P320 continues to dominate used gun sales because of its unmatched modularity and battle-proven reliability. Its serialized fire control unit (FCU) allows owners to swap frames, slides, and calibers without buying a new firearm — a huge draw for shooters seeking customization without breaking the bank.
On the used market, the P320’s popularity comes from availability, versatility, and affordability. Buyers can find gently used full-size or compact variants at significant discounts while still enjoying military-grade quality. Law enforcement trade-ins also contribute to steady inventory, keeping resale prices healthy.
2. Ruger Single Six – Revolver (Rank #1, Up From Previous Rank #3)
The Ruger Single Six remains a staple in the used market thanks to its legendary durability and convertible design. Many models include two cylinders — one for .22 LR and another for .22 WMR — giving owners flexibility for target shooting or small-game hunting.
Collectors and plinkers alike value it for its old-school single-action feel, smooth trigger, and rugged simplicity. The revolver’s all-steel construction makes it nearly indestructible, and even older models perform beautifully after decades of use.
Why it’s popular used: Affordable, accurate, and nearly indestructible — a forever gun for any rimfire enthusiast.
3. Springfield M1 Garand – Semi Auto Rifles – Rank #1
Few rifles hold the cultural and emotional weight of the Springfield M1 Garand. Nicknamed “the greatest battle implement ever devised,” this iconic semi-auto rifle draws steady demand in the used market from collectors, history buffs, and precision shooters alike.
Each Garand carries history — from WWII production runs to modern CMP (Civilian Marksmanship Program) rebuilds — making it both a shooting classic and an investment. Despite its age, its .30-06 power, accuracy, and distinctive “ping” make it a joy to shoot even today.
Why it’s popular used: Collectible heritage, battle-proven reliability, and the nostalgia of American firearms history.
4. Remington Model 700 – Bolt Action Rifles – Rank #1
The Remington 700 is the gold standard for bolt-action rifles, which explains its commanding presence in the used market. Hunters and long-range shooters seek it out for its exceptional accuracy, smooth action, and huge aftermarket ecosystem.
Because the Model 700 platform has been around for over 60 years, used examples are abundant — from vintage walnut-stocked hunting rifles to modern tactical builds. Even older models hold their value due to their interchangeable parts and proven design.
Why it’s popular used: Highly accurate, endlessly customizable, and available in every major caliber for every budget.
5. Winchester Model 94 – Lever Action Rifles – Rank #1
The Winchester Model 94 is synonymous with the lever-action rifle — and few guns capture nostalgia like it does. Its balance, quick cycling, and .30-30 chambering have made it a deer-hunting legend for over a century.
In the used market, the 94 remains strong because it’s lightweight, reliable, and deeply rooted in American hunting culture. Older pre-1964 models are especially prized for their craftsmanship, while newer versions remain accessible to everyday shooters.
Why it’s popular used: Classic design, dependable performance, and unmatched Americana appeal.
6. Thompson Center Encore – Single Shot Rifles – Rank #1
The T/C Encore is a used gun buyer’s dream for its modular, single-shot design. One receiver can host barrels for multiple calibers, from .223 to .50 cal muzzleloaders — offering incredible versatility for hunters and precision shooters who value efficiency over volume.
Used Encores sell quickly because they allow owners to build an entire firearm collection on a single platform. Barrel-swapping is easy, and the brand’s reputation for accuracy keeps resale values steady.
Why it’s popular used: Versatility across calibers, rugged simplicity, and exceptional single-shot precision.
7. Remington Model 1100 – Semi Auto Shotguns – Rank #1
The Remington 1100 has been a top seller since the 1960s, and it remains a hot commodity in the used shotgun market. Known for its soft recoil, reliable gas system, and graceful handling, it’s a favorite for both hunters and clay shooters.
Used 1100s are easy to find and maintain, and parts availability ensures long-term usability. Its elegant walnut stocks and traditional craftsmanship add collectible charm — especially for early-production models.
Why it’s popular used: Legendary smooth cycling, low recoil, and timeless aesthetics at a great value.
8. Remington 870 Wingmaster – Pump Action Shotguns – Rank #1
The Remington 870 Wingmaster defines dependability. Favored by hunters, sport shooters, and police alike, the 870’s solid steel receiver and simple pump action make it a firearm that “just works.”
On the used market, older Wingmasters are sought after for their superior fit and finish compared to modern Express models. Many buyers prefer these vintage versions for their hand-fitted parts and silky-smooth action, which outlast decades of use.
Why it’s popular used: Rock-solid reliability, classic craftsmanship, and endless parts availability.
9. Browning Citori – Shotgun, Over/Under (Rank #1)
The Browning Citori stands out in the used shotgun market as a premium over/under that blends luxury craftsmanship with competitive performance. Its deep blued barrels, fine walnut stock, and near-perfect balance make it a favorite for clay and upland shooters.
Used Citoris retain excellent resale value because Browning’s build quality ensures longevity. Many shooters upgrade to higher-end variants, fueling a steady cycle of pre-owned Citoris in near-perfect condition.
Why it’s popular used: High-end quality, smooth handling, and lasting resale value.
10. Browning BSS – Shotguns – Side By Side – Rank #1
The Browning BSS (Browning Side-by-Side) is revered by enthusiasts who appreciate classic doubles with modern reliability. Discontinued decades ago, it has become a sought-after collectible among side-by-side lovers for its tight lockup, robust build, and elegant styling.
Used BSS shotguns are prized for their craftsmanship and scarcity. Many buyers see them as heirlooms rather than tools — a connection to an era when side-by-sides ruled the upland fields.
Why it’s popular used: Rare, beautifully crafted, and mechanically superior among traditional double-barrels.
Key Takeaways from the Top Selling Used Guns September Report:
1. Remington Rules the Used Market: With three models in the top 10 — the Remington 700, 1100, and 870 Wingmaster — the brand continues its decades-long dominance in both rifles and shotguns.
2. Browning Makes a Comeback: The Browning BSS surged from #10 to #1 in its category, showing renewed collector and shooter interest in high-quality side-by-side shotguns.
3. Diverse Categories, Stable Leaders: The report highlights broad enthusiasm across firearm types — pistols, rifles, and shotguns all have category leaders maintaining the #1 spot month-over-month.
4. Classic Models Still Shine: From the Winchester Model 94 to the Springfield M1 Garand, these timeless firearms prove that vintage doesn’t mean outdated.
Expert Insight: What This Means for Buyers and Sellers
If you’re a buyer, this data suggests a strong resale value and sustained interest in well-maintained classics. For sellers, now is an excellent time to list reliable models like Remington 700s or Browning Citoris, as these continue to draw competitive bidding.
Used guns on GunBroker are more than just bargains — they’re a window into the preferences of American shooters, balancing practicality, heritage, and craftsmanship.
Final Thoughts
GunBroker’s September 2025 used firearm rankings show a market that’s both nostalgic and dynamic. While innovation drives new gun sales, the used market thrives on trust, tradition, and timeless design.
As we head into the final quarter of 2025, expect continued strength from these classic performers — and perhaps a few surprise contenders in the months ahead.
Pro Tips for Shopping Used Guns on GunBroker
- Check seller ratings and feedback
- Ask for detailed photos (especially bore and action)
- Review item descriptions for wear, upgrades, or included accessories
Explore the Best-Selling Used Guns on GunBroker
From modern pistols to heritage rifles, GunBroker’s used section is filled with proven platforms — many of which made September’s top-seller list.
👉 Browse All Used Firearms Now
Related Content: Second Shots: Finding Deals on Used Guns
Related Content: Top 5 Used Guns from the June 2025 GunBroker Best-Sellers List
Related Content: $20K+ Guns? See the 25 Most Expensive Guns Sold on GunBroker | July 2025
Related Content: Gun Deals: 6 Used Deer Rifles for Hunters
